Skip to main content

Dorothy Must Die (Dorothy Must Die #1) by Danielle Paige - Review

❋ ❋ 

Amy Gumm's life is turned upside down when a tornado picks up her family's trailer and deposits her in Oz. Yes, that Oz - the one with the yellow brick road, the munchkins, the witches, and the flying monkeys. Except this Oz isn't like the Oz she remembers from the books and movies, this one looks like it's been drained. Here the Good Witches can't be trusted, the Wicked Witches might be the good guys, winged monkeys can be executed for acts of rebellion, and the yellow brick road is crumbling. Dorothy is what happened to this Oz. Somehow she found her way back, seized control, and the power went to her head - now no one is safe. Amy is quickly recruited by the Revolutionary Order of the Wicked and is trained to fight. She might be the only one who can put an end to Dorothy's reign of terror once and for all.

For the most part, I liked Danielle Paige's dystopian take on Oz. The best part of the story is easily the premise and the setting. Oz is now so twisted, dark, and creepy - I was never quite sure what to expect from it. The change from a Technicolor wonderland to a dystopian wasteland is well realized and developed. Paige really gets across just how different her take on the place is right from the get go. I also enjoyed some little details and Easter eggs that make brief appearances in her novel.

However, as much as I liked those aspects, I had issues with other parts. I never really clicked with Amy. I'm not quite sure why, but her character consistently rubbed me the wrong way, especially as she begins to develop a conscience when an opportunity to get rid of Dorothy presents itself after weeks and weeks of training. On that note, the training slowed everything down dramatically. The middle of the story dragged on and on and on and doesn't really pick up until the last few pages of the book. There's also a bit of romance that goes absolutely nowhere between Amy and Nox. It doesn't do the story any favors and would have benefited from being entirely removed as it just slows it down even more.

Like I mentioned before, the story really doesn't take off again until the last few pages. The ending is entirely open and nothing really gets resolved. You know the tagline on the back of the book: "Your Mission: Remove The Tin Woodman's Heart. Steal The Scarecrow's Brain. Take The Lion's Courage. And Then - Dorothy Must Die. Only You Can Make Oz A Free Land Again." Yeah, it doesn't actually come into play until the very end - a bit deceiving, really. It relies on you reading the next book in the series. Obviously going in, I knew there was a sequel, The Wicked Will Rise, and that there was a third book coming called Yellow Brick War, plus all of the novellas, but I was really hoping that I could say "Ding dong everybody!" by the time I got to the end of the book.

Overall, I liked the concept and setting of Paige's debut, but I had too many issues with Dorothy Must Die to love it. I haven't decided yet if I want to continue on with the sequel. You may like this twisted take on Oz if you enjoyed Splintered by A.G. Howard, Regina, the Evil Queen, from Once Upon a Time, or "How The Wizard of Oz Should Have Ended".

I listened to this audiobook from January 13 - 20, 2016 and my review is also on Goodreads.


  1. Huh! I remember starting this book but never finishing it! Your review reminded me that I should probably pick it up again, thanks for that :)
    But ughhh. I'm kind of disappointed to hear about how slow it was and how unresolved the ending was. Soooo, then again, maybe I won't pick it up anytime soon.
    Oh other notes, how are you??
    - July,

    1. Not too bad, yourself? :)

      Regardless, happy reading!

  2. When this book first came out, I was very excited to read. A bunch of reviews later though, I'm not sure if I'll be picking it up after all. I've never read the original book but I do really love Wicked which is also a Wizard of Oz retelling. If you read the sequel, I'd love to know your thoughts on it :)

    1. I'm still up in the air on it, but I am kind of interested to see where it will go... Thanks for visiting my blog!

  3. Haha you're so kind in your review! When I read this one I absolutely hated it and it put me in a month and a half long book slump. I couldn't stand the writing, the romance went absolutely nowhere, and, yeah, it's super misleading on the back cover.

    1. Exactly! I was pretty disappointed in it, but there was just enough to keep me interested to finish it at least. Thanks for commenting, Sam!


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The French Connection by Robin Miller - Review

Top Ten Tuesday: Most Anticipated Books Releasing During the Second Half of 2024

Top Ten Tuesday: Books on My Summer 2024 TBR